THEM SEO and Web Design China logo
SEO chat beijing SEO chat china Chat with THEM now!
  • 简体中文 简体中文
  • English English
  • SEO
  • Web Development
  • SEM
  • Web Design
  • SEO Blog
  • Contact

Top topics

baidu
google
seo tips
drupal
ecommerce
seo-tools
web analytics

Bing and Google SEO comparison on Keywords

19
Jun
bing google

Bing gives a lot more weight to keywords in urls than google.

How do I know that

I tested it!Actually, I was comparing bing and google with this simple yet efficient tool, and this is how I got the first impression that bing answers were containing more often the keyword in the website url than on google.

So here’s the test I did

I searched for 50 random (almost) keywords, and I took for each query the first 50  responses of bing and the first 50 responses of google. Which means I checked  :

50(keywords) x 50(responses) x 2 (search engines : google and bing) = 5000 links

Don’t worry, I wrote a script for that ;o)
  
Then I checked if the keyword was (or wasn’t)  in the URL of the websites.

Example : I search for the keyword  “paris”

So I count this :
 keyword in url of the website
 

I don’t count that :

keyword not in url

And here’s what I found :

For Bing :  86,52%  of the first 50 websites contained the keyword in the URL.
For Google : 71,16% of the first 50 websites contained the keyword in the URL.

 

and don't tell me that this was really dependent on the keywords in my list of 50 keywords.Why? Because bing was showing more websites (with the keyword in the url) than google .... 92% of the time.

So, yes, putting the keywords in the url is really important for BOTH. But it seems that it’s a lot more important for the new Microsoft search engine “Bing”.

So if your strategy is focusing on bing for some niche keyword/market, don’t even think of not putting the keywords in your url or domain name.

Well, I think it’s a bad idea to put such a big weight on the keywords in the url, they should focus more on the content. Besides…this is gonna give more weight to hundred of thousands of parked domains… because domain resellers usually buy domains with keywords in them...

If you’re thankful happy I spent the day programming that script, and then sharing this information with you, I wouldn't mind you talk about it, vote for it on digg (check on the right side bar) or link back to here ;o)

Here are the stats for those of you who want all the figures :

keywords nb of sites with the keyword in the url for google nb of sites with the keyword in the url for bing
test 25 34
seo 28 33
funny 34 44
hello 42 45
welcome 25 20
surprise 35 47
love 39 47
there 32 45
boat 40 46
cars 30 38
design 45 44
pay 41 46
remember 37 47
lyrics 42 45
songs 25 32
manchester 46 48
paris 42 49
beijing 40 48
china 39 45
stop 44 47
photos 22 36
hill 44 47
bikes 30 40
pens 28 40
software 33 41
games 32 39
computers 17 35
folk 40 47
how 34 45
when 23 45
miss 40 49
area 36 46
paper 34 49
headset 32 46
iphone 42 41
news 37 43
php 47 48
drupal 43 44
marketing 37 46
english 35 38
write 28 47
script 43 48
manuel 35 48
language 35 45
tutorial 36 36
berlin 45 47
shanghai 33 44
trip 43 46
casino 32 43
finance 32 44
     
     
Average number of sites with the keyword in url (among the first 50) 35,58 43,26
total sites with keywords (of the 2500 checked) 1779 2163
total sites checked 2500 2500
% of sites among the 50 firsts with the keyword in the url 71,16% 86,52%

 

 

 

Submitted by Hacene on Fri, 06/19/2009 - 12:01
  • Hacene's blog
  • Share/Save
  • google
  • bing
  • keywords
  • seo
  • seo china
  • urls

Comments

#1 Bing gives a lot more weight to keywords in urls than google.

Submitted by Narendra (not verified) on Thu, 07/16/2009 - 04:51.

Yeah I do agree with you. I have seen this. I have a website and with a keyword Live Computer Support my website rank on 1st position in Bing but not in Google because. that keyword exists in my site URL so I think it ranks in Bing coz Bing gives preference the keyword in URL.

  • reply

#2 this might as well be true as

Submitted by ilya (not verified) on Sun, 12/06/2009 - 15:52.

this might as well be true as false. on every keywords the difference is so minor that you cannot really say whether it is because of keywords in urls or any other parameter. if you had 50 vs 10 then it would rather look true but 71 vs 87 does not really seem to be correct. also keep in mind that some webmasters might not pay too much attention to optimization for bing.

  • reply

#3 "on every keywords the

Submitted by admin on Tue, 12/08/2009 - 10:43.

"on every keywords the difference is so minor that you cannot really say whether it is because of keywords in urls or any other paramete

i can, because i didn't test one, two, but 50 keywords, and 50 x  50 x 2 =  5000 urls...

 

besides,  "bing was showing more websites (with the keyword in the url) than google .... 92% of the times" isn't that relevant!

"also keep in mind that some webmasters might not pay too much attention to optimization for bing."%

this statment is probably true, but  what does it change to the results of our study?  yes webmasters optimize more by checking on google and following google rules, but still bing rank higher those who have keywords in the url...

 

Since we wrote this article, we had the chance to test it so often now, that we create seperate websites for bing

  • reply

#4 "this statment is probably

Submitted by ilya (not verified) on Wed, 12/16/2009 - 05:03.

"this statment is probably true, but what does it change to the results of our study? yes webmasters optimize more by checking on google and following google rules, but still bing rank higher those who have keywords in the url..."

SERP results page may just be different if the website is only optimized for google.

  • reply

#5 SEO Services India

Submitted by SEO services India (not verified) on Thu, 07/08/2010 - 09:15.

Thanks for sharing information about Keyword diff between Google and Bing this types of information more important and valuable

  • reply

#6 Nice article.....I really

Submitted by best seo services company (not verified) on Thu, 08/05/2010 - 11:07.

Nice article.....I really impressed while reading your post.....Thank you so much , it will useful to every one....

  • reply

#7 Hi

Submitted by Seo Expert (not verified) on Thu, 08/26/2010 - 16:08.

i think google is the best.

  • reply

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Similar

  • National vs International Domain Name Extension and SEO
  • Google and javascript, new honeymoon
  • List of search engines in China
  • Yahoo Japan chooses Google as search partner
  • Search engine market share by country


share on facebook

Recent blog posts

  • Bing Searches for a Partner in China
  • Google Acquires Visual Search Engine Like.com
  • Tencent Acquires Comsenz and Becomes Leader of Chinese BBS
  • Google now lists more results from the same domain
  • China's E-commerce Market up by 60% in Q1
  • How to Register a .CN or a Chinese Domain Name
  • List of search engines in China
  • China Mobile and Xinhua to Build Search Engine
  • How do Search Engines Interpret Non-Latin Characters?
  • Google is Using You to Promote Your Competitors!
more

Recent comments

  • answer this post
    1 sec ago
  • cheap nfl jerseys
    44 min 25 sec ago
  • I am Japanese. I am
    1 day 13 hours ago
  • hey
    4 days 2 hours ago
  • web design company
    6 days 1 hour ago
  • Worldpay?
    1 week 16 hours ago
  • Hi
    1 week 17 hours ago
  • According to Chinese research
    3 weeks 5 days ago
  • Thanks for u r information
    3 weeks 6 days ago
  • Nice article.....I really
    4 weeks 22 hours ago

MyBlogLog Community

My Ranking

Url (ex : www.amazon.com):

Keywords (ex : books):

Email (ex : my_name@my_mail.com):

Contact us | About us | SEO Blog | Site Map

Recent blog posts

  • Bing Searches for a Partner in China
  • Google Acquires Visual Search Engine Like.com
  • Tencent Acquires Comsenz and Becomes Leader of Chinese BBS
  • Google now lists more results from the same domain
  • China's E-commerce Market up by 60% in Q1
  • How to Register a .CN or a Chinese Domain Name
  • List of search engines in China
  • China Mobile and Xinhua to Build Search Engine
  • How do Search Engines Interpret Non-Latin Characters?
  • Google is Using You to Promote Your Competitors!
more

Site map

  • SEO
    • SEO Services
    • SEO Take-a-Look (for Free!)
    • SEO Audit
    • SEO Monitoring
    • What is SEO?
    • Do you need SEO?
    • Choose THEM China
    • Google Baidu Ranking Tool
  • Web Development
    • Website Localization
  • Search Engine Marketing
  • Web Design
  • About THEM

Tag cloud

acquisition advertising adwords baidu bing blocked china chinese cms drupal ecommerce facebook google google image search internet japan mobile rank ranking search-engine search engine sem seo seo-tools seo tips sns statistics taobao web design yahoo
more tags